"My interest in giving you this site for two years is not unselfish." Hugh Codding said that to Santa Rosa's Farmers Market Committee in January 1950. He was offering the market a free acre in the middle of his new Montgomery Village development. He wanted the market's traffic for his shops, and he wanted "another attraction to offer home buyers in the area," as The Press Democrat recounted for the center's 75th anniversary.
The houses went on sale next to that attraction. Montgomery Village opened on June 3, 1950, with 13 businesses and the Redwood Empire Farmers' Market. The paper reported that the first homes around it sold for an average of $7,800. By 1955 the planned community had 2,600 homes, along with a pool, schools and churches, according to the center's own history page.
More than 76 years later the arrangement still works much the same way. The house in Montgomery Village is mostly a known quantity. The price you pay mostly reflects what sits around it, and in 2026 both of the big things nearby are changing.
The house is the part that stays the same
Codding wanted variety. He told the paper in 1949 that each house would have its own layout "to get away from too much uniformity." Even so, the neighborhood has a recognizable type. A typical example from recent MLS records is a single-story mid-century ranch built in 1951, with 1,417 square feet on a 6,175-square-foot lot and a concrete perimeter foundation. Size runs fairly consistent across sales too. In the six months through mid-November 2026, Montgomery Village homes that reported their living area averaged about 1,400 square feet.
The updates also tend to repeat. Recent listings commonly show refinished hardwood floors, updated kitchens and baths, newer windows, and roof or exterior work. A 1950s Montgomery Village remodel documented by Christopherson Builders in 2024 opened up a walled-in kitchen and modernized a bath while keeping the original tub. It also turned a rec room into a private suite that could work as an attached ADU. That's one project, but it shows how much room these floor plans leave for change.
Here's what the market is paying for that house right now. In the six months through mid-November 2026, about 30 homes sold in Montgomery Village. They averaged roughly $781,000, took about 60 days to sell, and closed at about 98.6 percent of list price. Over the same six months, Santa Rosa as a whole averaged about $856,000 across 957 sales, with homes taking about 75 days to sell at 98.7 percent of list. For a wider benchmark, the California Association of Realtors reported a Sonoma County median of $875,000 for existing single-family homes in September 2026, up 10.1 percent from September 2025.
So over the past six months, a Montgomery Village home sold for about $75,000 less than the citywide average and sold about two weeks faster. Thirty sales is a small sample, and one sale on Sonoma Avenue near $1.9 million pulls the average up. The broad pattern still holds. The houses are modest and fairly alike, and they sell quickly. When house after house offers the same thing, buyers are mostly paying for what's around them.
The Village keeps adding reasons to walk over
Codding's original draw is still there and still growing. Montgomery Village sits between Farmers Lane and Hahman Drive and has about 280,000 square feet of retail. This year it gained two tenants that once would have meant a drive across town.
Apple moved its Santa Rosa store out of Santa Rosa Plaza and into an 8,684-square-foot space at 720 Farmers Lane, The Press Democrat reported in January. Later that month, on January 26, Blue Bottle Coffee opened its first North Bay café at the Village, near See's Candies, Mendocino Farms and Salt & Straw, according to The Press Democrat.
The everyday stores matter just as much to someone who lives a few blocks away. The center's current directory still lists Lucky Supermarket, a U.S. Post Office and Copperfield's Books. It also lists Sweetgreen, Shake Shack and Fieldwork, plus older favorites such as Boudin SF Bakery. Madewell, Palmetto Superfoods, Poppy Bank, and Beach by Everything But Water are posted as coming soon.
The center also runs a community calendar. Weekend Santa Sightings are scheduled from Saturday, Nov. 28 through Sunday, Dec. 20, and in summer Fieldwork's terrace hosts a monthly Sunset Socials evening with local live music and vendors. The center is investing and leasing up, so the amenity Codding sold houses on keeps getting better.
Forty-nine acres of old freeway land, now headed for parkland
The second neighbor is newer and still unfinished, which is why a buyer should understand it now.
Between 1952 and 1972, Caltrans bought a strip of land to carry Highway 12 east from Farmers Lane through Spring Lake Park toward Melita Road. The freeway extension was never built. The state dropped the extension plans in 2014. In October 2024, Santa Rosa completed its purchase of the 49-acre corridor for just over $1.8 million, the appraised value. A $1 million grant from the Sonoma County Agricultural Preservation & Open Space District and community donations covered part of the cost, The Press Democrat reported.
This land now makes up the Southeast Greenway, a strip about 300 feet wide and roughly two miles long. It runs from Farmers Lane east to Spring Lake Regional Park. Along the way it passes Montgomery High School, crosses Yulupa Avenue and Summerfield Road, and then turns northeast and climbs toward Spring Lake, as The Press Democrat described the route in 2013. Homes on Mayette and Hoen avenues sit along the corridor.
On June 16, 2026, the City Council approved a master planning agreement with CMG Landscape Architecture. The Press Democrat reported the contract with the San Francisco-based firm at $2.67 million. The first community workshops were held Nov. 4 and 5 at Montgomery Middle/High School, and the City expects a recommended master plan in summer 2027, according to its September notice. A separate technical design phase follows the master plan, according to the project's planning page. Ideas already in discussion include play space for young children, a multiuse path over several creeks and through a restored walnut grove, and a community garden, The Press Democrat reported in September. Residents can share their own ideas through the project's online survey, available in English and Spanish.
"People have been waiting for this for a long time," Thea Hensel, a longtime supporter of the effort, told The Press Democrat. "Now the fun part is really starting."
Not all of the old right-of-way is going to the park. The state kept about 9 acres near Farmers Lane, to be sold separately for housing of up to 244 units, according to The Press Democrat's 2024 report. If you're looking at a house near the Farmers Lane end of the corridor, plan for both a park and new neighbors as part of the long-term picture.
What this means when you're comparing Santa Rosa neighborhoods
In Montgomery Village today, you're buying a 1950s ranch of about 1,400 square feet, at a price that has recently run below the city average. Within walking distance is a shopping center that has added Apple and Blue Bottle this year. Along one edge of the area, 49 acres are being planned as public parkland through summer 2027. Today's prices reflect the Village as it stands. The greenway is still a plan with a schedule, and buyers this year are purchasing before it's built.
That changes how to compare homes here. Two houses with similar square footage and finishes can differ more in where they sit than in what's inside. Here's how I'd walk a buyer through it:
- Map each home against both neighbors. Measure the walk to the Village, and check whether the home is near the corridor, the Farmers Lane end where housing is planned, or neither.
- Price the condition gap yourself. The houses are similar enough that updates such as a reworked kitchen, newer windows or a converted rec room explain most of the price differences between nearby sales.
- Visit at the times you'd actually live there. Try a Saturday at the Village during the holiday weekends, and walk the streets near Hoen Avenue on a weekday morning.
- Keep an eye on the greenway schedule. Master planning runs through summer 2027, and each phase will give you a clearer picture of what will sit next to the homes along the corridor.
For context across town, my earlier look at how Fountaingrove and Coffey Park rebuilt after the same fire compares two other Santa Rosa neighborhoods. The Santa Rosa neighborhood page shows what's on the market now.
If Montgomery Village is on your list, let's walk the streets you're considering together, from the Village side to the greenway side, and talk through what each home's location adds before you write an offer. Schedule a free consultation with Michael Pellegrini to talk through your options, no pressure.